Our weekly interview podcasts are free for all of our subscribers. But about 40% of our site’s content is reserved for our paid subscribers. It’s not very expensive—jump in and get all of our coverage during this important election year! Paid subscribers will get extra content in the form of our “One More Thing” extra question with Judge Gilliard. Hint: We go back decades for this talk…
🎙️ This Week on the So, Does It Matter? One-On-One Podcast — Straight Talk with Judge Maryanne Gilliard
Retired Superior Court Judge Maryanne Gilliard has seen California’s criminal justice system from every angle — as a prosecutor, a senior official in state government, and for nearly three decades on the bench.
In this week’s One-On-One Podcast, Jon sits down with Judge Gilliard for a candid and, at times, sobering discussion about what she believes has gone wrong in California — and how policy decisions coming out of Sacramento have fundamentally changed how justice is delivered.
Drawing on decades of firsthand experience, Gilliard explains how she approached her role as a judge — not as an activist, but as an “umpire,” calling balls and strikes based on the law as written. But over time, she says, the rules themselves began to change in ways that made that role increasingly difficult.
The conversation dives into major shifts in criminal justice policy, including changes to parole eligibility, sentencing structures, and diversion programs — and what those changes mean in real-world terms, from the courtroom to the streets.
Gilliard also walks through specific examples that shaped her views, including cases she presided over and policy changes she believes have weakened accountability and deterrence. She argues that many of these decisions are being driven by political priorities rather than public safety — and that the consequences are now being felt across the state.
Jon and Judge Gilliard also discuss the broader philosophy behind these reforms, the role of elected officials in shaping the system, and what — if anything — can be done to reverse course.
Whether you agree with her or not, this is a rare opportunity to hear directly from someone who spent a career inside the system — and is now speaking freely about what she saw.
If you want a firsthand perspective on how California’s justice system has evolved — and why one longtime judge believes it’s headed in the wrong direction — this is a conversation worth hearing.
🎥 Watch the full conversation above — and find the video and podcast players below
If you want to play the audio right here, this is the player:
If you’d like to listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or other platforms, click here.
You can find this video on YouTube here. (You can easily embed a video from YouTube into your social media channels! Spread the word.)
Join the growing community of hundreds of paid subscribers who get 100% of Jon’s reporting and analysis. Free subscribers see about 60%—but the whole picture, the deeper dives, and the extras are reserved for paid members. If you value independent journalism that cuts through the noise, this is the place to stand with me. All the reasons to upgrade are right here—come inside. It’s priced at less than half of what Substack recommends… Start with a free trial!
EXCLUSIVE “ONE MORE THING” EXTRA VIDEO BELOW… It’s a thank you to our paid subscribers!
