Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jim Cunneen's avatar

Mamdani’s proposed polices are terrible and far fetched, in my view. Appreciate the post. A few thoughts -

1)The unifying message from majorities in diverse states was a rebuke on President Trump’s erratic, dark Presidency.

2) But it’s hard to pinpoint any credible broad policy oriented conclusion of how to oppose Trump effectively - progressives Democratic leaders claim voters, particularly the young, want socialism, while the moderates assert center-left not left is the answer (I’d prefer center or slightly center-right candidates in both parties!).

3) You assert a key policy conclusion is the Democratic voters embrace of socialism, but that’s not what happened in NJ nor VA. The Dem victors talked affordability. And you leave out Trump’s embrace of big government including more state control of private companies, bullying companies seeking regulatory approvals, huge spending, and tariff taxes!

4) I’m not a member of the Democratic nor Republican Party (where I spent my whole political life as a member) but I have an observation! Given the Democrats running the spectrum from moderate to socialist had success, a key takeaway to their success was the contrast between the young, optimistic nominees talking about affordability in New Jersey, Virginia, New York, and a very old, cranky, nativist, big government power amassing president who does t seem focused on affordability.

4) In 2026 and 2028, I hope there are more center-left, not socialist candidates in the Democratic Party, and more Republicans willing to openly defy Trump.

Expand full comment

No posts